alulu | Learnovate

Can Rewards and Intrinsic Motivation Work Together?

What if we have been looking at the relationship between rewards and learning motivation the wrong way?

Can Rewards and Intrinsic Motivation Work Together | aulu x Learnovate

For longer than anyone can remember, the relationship between learning and rewards has been cast as overtly negative. Educators and trainers generally don’t like them and even modern variations on the reward concept like digital badging had a only small number of supporters.

Popular consensus infers that when rewards are introduced to any type of learning scenario, they immediately have an undermining effect eroding precious intrinsic motivation.

But is that really true?

Anecdotally, yes, when crudely applied, and usually based on only one aspect like completion, rewards can have a negative effect on motivation.

However, there really is more than one way to consider rewards in learning and the significant lack of in-depth studies in the past indicates there are many aspects of rewards utilisation during a course of study that are misunderstood.

It’s for that very reason alulu sought out the capabilities of world class researchers at Learnovate to help shed light on a highly misunderstood and marginalised topic

 On one side, there is the argument that external rewards can encourage people to participate, stay motivated and achieve their goals. On the other, there is the concern that rewards can actually take away from the genuine interest and satisfaction that comes from learning something new.

But does it really have to be one or the other?

What if intrinsic and extrinsic motivation could work together? What if, instead of seeing rewards as something that competes with our natural desire to learn, we looked at how they might complement it?

It is a fascinating and critical question, particularly when you think about the challenges organisations face with learning today particularly as AI plays an ever-greater role in how work and learning gets done Motivation and the encouragement of positive and habitual learning activity is more important than ever for both skilled and unskilled workers.

Businesses are investing more than ever in upskilling, AI literacy and professional development, but getting people to complete that learning still remains a challenge. People start with good intentions, but somewhere along the way, life happens, priorities change and motivation starts to fade.

So how do we help people not only get started, but keep going?

Taking a closer look at the research

At Learnovation 2026 in Dublin, our own Myles Thies joined Dr Peter Gillis, Research Lead at Learnovate, to share insights from the research commissioned by alulu.

The research explored whether external incentives and tangible rewards could play a role in encouraging positive, sustainable learning behaviours and academic motivation, with a particular focus on blended learning in higher education.

It brought together existing research from psychology, neuroscience, motivation theory and educational studies to explore a question that has been debated for decades.

Can external rewards support learning without taking away from someone’s own motivation to learn?

One of the concepts explored was the undermining effect, which is associated with Self-Determination Theory.

Put simply, this is the idea that rewarding someone for something they already enjoy doing can sometimes make them less interested in the activity itself, particularly when the reward is no longer there.

And it makes sense that this could happen.

If someone genuinely enjoys learning something, we would not want to turn that experience into something they only do because there is a reward attached.

But this is where things get interesting.

The findings also point to a much more nuanced relationship between rewards and motivation. It is not necessarily a case of rewards being good or bad.

Its how they are used, when they are introduced and what they recognise that matters.

And that gives us a different way of thinking about positive reinforcement in learning.

Five interesting takeaways from the research

1. Recognise progress, rather than create pressure

There is a big difference between recognising someone’s achievement and using a reward to pressure them into doing something.

One of the recommendations from the research is to use rewards as feedback on progress or recent performance, rather than as a way of controlling behaviour.

I think this is an important distinction.

We spend so much time focusing on the end result of learning, whether that is completing a course, passing an assessment or earning a qualification, that we sometimes overlook everything someone achieves along the way.

What if we were better at recognising those smaller moments of progress?

Not because we want to pressure someone into completing the next module, but because their effort and achievement deserve to be acknowledged.

2. Not all learning is the same, so why would we motivate everyone in the same way?

The research highlights that different types of learning can benefit from different approaches to motivation.

For straightforward, repetitive or quantity-based activities, tangible rewards can be useful.

But when learning involves creativity, problem-solving or deeper thinking, encouraging curiosity, choice and genuine interest becomes particularly important.

It is a useful reminder that there is no one-size-fits-all approach.

The way we encourage someone to complete mandatory compliance training might look quite different from how we support someone developing a new creative skill.

The learning matters, the person matters and the way we recognise progress should reflect that.

3. Sometimes, the hardest part is simply getting started

We talk a lot about course completion, but what about all the people who never really get going in the first place?

Most of us have been there. We sign up for something with every intention of doing it, but then work gets busy, other priorities take over and suddenly weeks have passed.

It does not necessarily mean we are not interested or that we do not see the value.

Sometimes we just need a little encouragement to take that first step.

The research suggests that tangible incentives can be particularly useful for less engaging activities or for encouraging people to get started.

Of course, that does not mean we should reward every single action. It is about being thoughtful about when an incentive might be useful and what behaviour we are trying to support.

4. Recognition is about more than tangible rewards

When people hear the word “reward”, they often immediately think of money, gifts or something physical.

But recognition comes in many forms.

A simple thank you, positive feedback, encouragement or acknowledgement of someone’s effort can be incredibly meaningful.

The research recommends considering tangible rewards alongside these other forms of recognition, rather than treating them as competing approaches.

And I think this is where the conversation becomes particularly interesting.

Why should a practical reward and a genuine sense of achievement be mutually exclusive?

If someone has worked hard to complete a learning milestone, surely we can recognise that effort in more than one way.

5. Give people choice

This one is particularly important.

What motivates one person might mean very little to someone else.

Some people enjoy public recognition. Others would prefer something more personal. Some appreciate a practical reward, while others are motivated by the satisfaction of seeing how far they have come.

The research highlights the importance of understanding individual preferences and giving learners choice.

Rather than assuming everyone will respond to the same incentive, we should be thinking about how to make recognition more relevant and meaningful to the individual.

After all, learning is personal. Why should recognition be any different?

So what does this mean for learning and development?

For me, one of the most interesting parts of this conversation is how relevant it is to the challenges organisations are dealing with every day.

We have fantastic learning platforms, increasingly sophisticated content and more opportunities to develop skills than ever before.

But access to learning is not the same as engagement, and engagement does not automatically translate into completion.

People start courses because they want to learn, because their organisation requires them to, or because they know the outcome will benefit them.

But the benefits are often somewhere in the future.

The effort, on the other hand, is happening right now.

And that is where things can start to fall apart. The challenging middle and getting to the end where we all want to be with the skills, experience and capability required

When someone is juggling work, family and everything else life throws at them, the promise of a qualification or a new skill several months down the line is not always enough to keep them moving.

So perhaps we need to think a little differently about what happens between the start and the finish.

How can we make progress feel meaningful along the way? How can we recognise the effort people are putting in? And how can we use positive reinforcement to support the motivation they already have, rather than trying to replace it?

These are the questions that make this research so interesting.

It is not about throwing rewards at a problem and hoping people complete more learning.

It is about understanding motivation and designing learning experiences that help people keep going.

How this research is influencing alulu

At alulu, we have always been fixated  on what happens between someone starting their learning and actually completing it.

We know that creating great learning content is important, but we also know that even the best learning can struggle to hold someone’s attention when competing priorities get in the way.

That is why we focus on positive reinforcement, developing learner agency and recognising meaningful progress throughout the learning journey.

alulu works alongside existing learning platforms, connecting learning milestones to real-world value through access to retailer-funded savings.

The idea is not to replace someone’s natural motivation to learn or make rewards the reason they are learning in the first place.

It is to explore how recognising progress in a practical, meaningful way can provide a little extra encouragement along the journey.

The research we commissioned through Learnovate continues to influence how we think about product development, learner choice and how rewards are introduced into the learning experience.

And importantly, we see this as an ongoing learning process ourselves.

There is still more research to be done, particularly around how these approaches influence engagement, persistence and completion in real learning environments.

We are excited to continue exploring those questions as alulu develops.

Perhaps it is time to rethink the debate?

About the research

The Effect of Rewards on Learning Motivation was presented at Learnovation 2026 by Myles Thies of alulu and Dr Peter Gillis, Research Lead at Learnovate.

Commissioned by alulu and led by Dr Gillis, the research explored the potential effectiveness of external incentives and tangible rewards in supporting positive, sustainable learning behaviours and academic motivation.

The research continues to inform alulu’s thinking around positive reinforcement, learner engagement and product development, while creating opportunities for further investigation.

Let us keep the conversation going.

We would love to hear how your organisation is approaching learning motivation, engagement and completion or how we could collaborate on research into the widening field of rewards, motivation and learning?